banner shape
banner shape
    November 17, 2026
Meaningful People

DEBATE: He’s Been Calling Out Jews. Now He’s Face-to-Face With a Rabbi

album-art
00:00

Share

Mike Caldarise, the man behind Fight for Jackson, has spent years calling out the Orthodox community in Ocean County, New Jersey. When he saw Rabbi Elchanan Shoff's Lakewood and Jackson Ask Me Anything videos, he left a challenge in the comments: these guys will never sit down with me. So Rabbi Shoff did.

What follows is an unfiltered conversation about kosher supermarkets, bloc voting, Hatzolah, the Tyler Oliveira video, the word "goy," and whether two people who see the same neighborhood so differently can actually understand each other.

This episode is sponsored by:

► Aura House

A sleek, flame free cold air diffuser that fills your home with a five star hotel scent, with no parabens or phthalates. Use code MEANINGFUL15 for 15% off.

https://aurahouse.com

_________________

► Kosher Morocco Tours

Daven at the kever of R' Yitzchak Abuchatzeira on his 115th yahrtzeit this January. Join the full Yeshiva Week journey for men and women, January 17 to 24, 2027, led by Rabbi Mordechai Lebhar, or the men only journey, January 20 to 26, 2027, with the Limanover Rebbe. Can't do the whole week? Come for Shabbos at the Park Hyatt Marrakech or fly in just for the Hilula. Kevarim across Morocco, the Sahara, five star hotels and Glatt Kosher, Cholov Yisroel and Pas Yisroel meals, all handled from start to finish. Packages start at $999.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc96kPXzehexl31rt6ZnrT7t3HO6vLCr3-Uwun_uP3QIt3Apg/viewform

516-559-7788

info@koshermoroccotours.com

_________________

► Upscale Legacy Pesach

Spend Pesach 2027, April 20 to 30, at the M Resort and Spa in Las Vegas. A full kids and teen program, Yoni Z and Aryeh Kunstler, dueling pianos and kumzitzes, plus shiurim from Rabbi Mordechai Lebhar, Rabbi Shmuel and Rebbetzin Devorah Miller, Rabbi Yaakov Jackness and more.

https://upscalelegacy.com

844-987-7225

info@upscalelegacy.com

Timestamps:

0:00 Intro: Meet Mike Calderese of Jackson Strong
2:54 Religion, Spirituality and Two Family Men
5:29 The Ask Me Anything Series and an Aggressive First Message
13:58 What Mike Really Thinks About Orthodox Jews
16:27 Bloc Voting, Kosher Supermarkets and Shabbos Closures
24:45 Choice or Force: Who Gets to Change a Neighborhood?
30:55 Chosen People, Superiority and "Protecting" Ocean County
34:03 Antisemitism and the Question of "Why"
39:00 Are People Born Good or Evil?
49:29 Is Good and Evil Objective? Defining God
58:50 Yin and Yang, and What Tefillin Mean
1:02:57 What Mike Admires About the Orthodox Community
1:04:42 Why the Jewish Community Sticks Together
1:07:11 Hatzolah: A Great Service With a PR Problem
1:10:32 Reading Mike's Messages Out Loud
1:15:29 "I'm a Mirror": Tyler Oliveira and the Lakewood Video
1:26:49 Kiryas Joel, Zoning and Welfare
1:29:09 January 6th and How Every Story Gets Spun
1:30:44 When the Neighbors Change: Barbecues, Parking and Shuls
1:37:34 The Word "Goy" and "Goyslop"
1:40:16 Should Kids From Different Communities Play Together?
1:47:45 Judging the Whole Person
1:50:09 Mike's Plan: Round Tables, Real Data and Welcoming Neighbors
1:53:19 Closing